Lea Michele
Listen, I LOVE a spray tan myself but Lea's is so dark that it's messing with her illusion netting! Also, get ready for a LOT of platforms. I can't believe they're coming back but I guess this WAS 14 years ago.
Amber Riley
This color is great on her and her shoes are BLUE, which I love. I do think this feels a little bit like Your Favorite English Teacher Looks Just Great At Graduation -- this was before she got a stylist who started regularly nailing it. (The first season of Glee had JUST finished airing. God, that first season was SO good!)
Jenna Ushkowitz
She obviously doesn't look BAD but this is a bit underwhelming. I think the whole cast kinda leveled up, styling wise, in the next few years.
Heather Morris
These shoes are SO 2010. I am sure I had a pair myself. In looking up when she had her babies -- 2013 and 2015 -- I just found out that she won The Masked Dancer, which I didn't know was a thing, in 2022! This makes sense; she is a GREAT dancer. Anyway, I always liked her as a celeb and hope she is well. This cast has gone through a lot of tragedy. (I downloaded Naya, and she's next, but I didn't get photos of Cory Monteith or Marc Salling, although they attended. I also didn't grab pics of any of the other dudes on Glee because I just...did not want to. They looked like themselves!)
Naya Rivera
This dress is lovely on her and she was so gorgeous. Her story is SO sad and she's so missed. She was SO GOOD on Glee and I always thought should have had a bigger career.
Jayma Mays
This is VERY cute. You could wear this now. I also had this haircut.
Selena Gomez
These shoes are RIDICULOUS and also this was an era when everyone needed a lipstick. The back of this dress is all silver, which makes it a bit more interesting. Selena Gomez of 2010, hang in there: You're gonna end up nominated for an Emmy for a DELIGHTFUL TV show where you get to hang out with LEGENDS.
Shailene Woodley
This is fine, but she eventually got a more interesting place. It's worth noting that I believe this was during her stint of Secret Lives of the American Teenager, one of the WORST SHOWS OF ALL TIME and not even her great talents could save it. Related: Where IS Shailene Woodley? (I guess Pretty Little Lies was recent enough and she can afford to be choosy.)
Channing Tatum and Jenna Dewan
Very notably NOT still married.
Emma Roberts
This needs, like, a little moto jacket to tie in the shoes. I honestly think I still own these shoes. I need to clean my closet, thank you for the reminder, Emma.
Nina Dobrev
Actually, I still love this.
The KardashiJenners and Lamar Odom
All of these faces are radically different now, other than Kendall (who just looks young here), Kourtney (who looks THE SAME), honestly mostly Kimberly, and, of course, Lamar. As far as I know, Lamar is currently doing well and I hope that continues; I have a huge soft spot for him. (I also think this version of Khloe is a babe.)
Sarah Ramos
I love her and think she is so talented and I do not know what happened here? She looks like your very favorite, sweetest babysitter. Like, does she have her backpack? Sarah!
Mae Whitman
I kinda wish the skirt were black but I love this on my beloved Mae Whitman (who, last I saw on Insta, was about to have a baby. Mazel tov, Mae!).
Ariel Winter
I like this for her -- remember when she went through a VERY sexy period? This is not that -- even though my grandma literally had sheets in this pattern. The boots are fun on her. I think she was going through some insane stuff with her Mom at this point -- she ended up getting emancipated.
Sarah Hyland
This looks cheaper than it had to have been? Luckily, she really bounced back -- I feel like there were several years where she REALLY nailed the Emmys.
Ayla Kell, Josie Loren and Cassie Scerbo
JUSTICE FOR MAKE IT OR BREAK IT!!!!!! That show was my JAM. Sadly, this is the only pic I have of all three women.
Cassie Scerbo
Why did we wear this shoes? However, while I'm here: She was GREAT on Make It Or Break It and like so many people in this slideshow, could absolutely nail a White Lotus. I guess I'm glad she made all that Sharknado money!
Anna Torv
Anna Torv. You talented noble land mermaid. This is terrible.
Levi Johnston
Informative Caption calls him "actor Levi Johnston" and that is GENEROUS. As his Wiki says, he "is best known as the twice-former fiancé of Bristol Palin and father of their son Tripp. He first received media attention in August 2008 when U.S. vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin announced that her daughter Bristol was five months pregnant by Johnston and that the two were engaged. The couple ultimately ended their relationship, and Johnston and the Palin family engaged in several public feuds." THAT WAS A TIME TO BE ALIVE. His whole Wiki is a RIDE. Anyway, he's now, I think, working as an electrician in Alaska, which is good money AND of service to your community, so good for him!
Ashley Greene
Huh, I like it! This is unobjectionable in retrospect.
Nikki Blonsky
She looks good! Although I hope that now, in 2024 -- I just wrote 2014, save me -- we'd see her styled more youthfully. This feels like something you'd see on Kate Winslet and she's only 22.
Shay Mitchell
CLASSIC 2010.
Ashley Benson
I kinda love it? (I always thought she and Cassie Scerbo could play an updated Jessica and Elizabeth Wakefield, except they're both kinda a Jessica.)
Lucy Hale
She is adorable but I don't know about the belt.
Troian Bellisario
The shoes are somewhat underwhelming but I think she could drag this out and wear it now!
Cat Deeley
What were any of us thinking? Truly.
Chace Crawford
"Hey, we did Rock Paper Scissors and that's why I'm the person here from Gossip Girl."
Mary Lynn Rajskub
She has weirdly tan feet here. Usually it's the other way around. Having said that: She looks cute! I think SHE drew the straw to be the 24 cast representative.
Yvonne Strahovski
EXCELLENT shoe choice.
Joshua Jackson
And then Pacey showed up. (For Fringe. But always as Pacey, let's get real.)