Jake Gyllenhaal, Rachel McAdams

I almost gave this a full Well Played, but then I got a look at the jacket, and it looks like it's been pinned together really awkwardly above the button -- specifically so she could wear it without a shirt underneath but it wouldn't flap open on her. Which... I feel you, but could no one figure out how to do that... CALMLY? It's jacking with the jacket's lines. The IDEA of the look, I really like, though. The ESPYs feel very much more like a pantsuit kind of night than a big ol' gown.

Rachel McAdams

Those are some sole-cracking shoes right there. I cannot imagine the numbing agents they required.

Rachel McAdams

This is for all you hair lovers out there. People were going nuts for her head the other day, and I just wanted you to have that opportunity once more.

Peyton Manning, Rachel McAdams

"No c'mere, I need to know. DID 'fetch' ever happen? Because I have a bet with Brady that people quoting that part of the movie means 'fetch' DID happen and you would be the perfect deciding vote and I want to call and REALLY deflate that guy's balls."

ESPYs Fine or Fab: Rachel McAdams

I hope their chemistry is better in the movie. (In fairness, it looks like it was very warm and bright there, meaning her choice of outfit may not have been optimal and her lack of sunglasses may have been devastating.) [Photos: Getty]