Brie Larson

I do really love this on her.

Ruth Negga

And this is a superb party dress as well.

Nicki Minaj

I love that she wore this. It was so unexpected from her, and it's fantastic.

Miranda Kerr

Twirly and delicious.

Denee Benton

I would like this even if it didn't accidentally coordinate with the backdrop.

Dove Cameron

That's a really striking version of it as well.

Gugu Mbatha-Raw

There's no way I wasn't going to love this.

Jaime King

Or this. Both of those hit my sweet spot.

Selena Gomez

She isn't often this polished. 

Emmy Rossum

This is the kind of stuff I do generally think of when I imagine an OdlR party dress.

Blake Lively

This got wasted, sandwiched as it was in the midst of one of her epic 9-outfit PR onslaughts.

Nicole Kidman

Graceful; elegant.

Kate Bosworth

Delightful.

Jaime King

She's a big Monse person, so it makes sense that she'd get some OdlRs from them; this is a nice one.

Natalia Dyer

Natalia is in red on the far left, burning a totally good day dress at Comic-Con. Not that you shouldn't want to look nice at that, but it deserved a better photo op.

Brie Larson

A BIT binding-looking, but it's nice.

Daisy Ridley

I liked this better from the back; something about the hemline on the front feels a bit juvenile.

Elisabeth Moss

I only just noticed his signature on the skirt. I don't like the shoes, but the overall VIBE here is good? I assume the leather jacket was her addition, though, and that's part of what's good.

Jessica Chastain

That's a bit stodgy on Chasty there.

Jessica Chastain

Sure, why not!

Claire Foy

I guess knots were a theme, however briefly. This leaves me cold. Maybe without the small train, or... as a dress? It's got a thrown-together vibe somehow.

Nicole Kidman

She clearly liked this, because she vamped on the red carpet.

Blake Lively

Underwhelming on all fronts, particularly the styling.

Rihanna

This was custom, and yet it feels exactly like so many other things she's worn or would soon wear. The shirt also looks kind of cheap. Rihanna pulls it off because she's Rihanna, but: I'm chilly on this one too.

Kerry Washington

Does this feel too small on her?

Reese Witherspoon

This feels like kin to Thandie Newton's white Monse that had the metallic on the hem. It also sort of looks like Reese has shiny Rapunzel hair.

Alek Wek

Well, she's certainly showcasing the boots.

Rachel Weisz

This needs to be entirely re-tailored.

Kate Bosworth

I want to see that with a leather motorcycle jacket. I don't think the yellow and pink are hanging out nicely together.

Zoe Kravitz

DRAMA. But that kind of fabric doesn't respond well to EVER having to bunch, and it looks like a pink paper bag.

Jaime King

This needed... a different lining and/or bodice approach.

Michelle Pfeiffer

It's hard to get mad at her.

SJP

I can TOTALLY get mad at this, though. And I will, and am.

Kiernan Shipka

Kiernan Shipka is giving it her all. I can't get into dresses and pants, but she's making the best argument she can.

Emma Watson

Emma wore a lot of OdlR on her Beauty and the Beast tour, and a LOT of it was pants-based. We didn't have those photos, but imagine colorful bodices and then that exact same shapeless pair of pants, and you've pretty much got it.

Jessica Chastain

Putting the signature all over it doesn't make it awesome, y'all.

How Good Was It: Oscar de la Renta in 2017

Did the brand turn it around?