Evangeline Lilly

Okay, so I think the hair was a step too far -- she cannot resist going slightly crackpot, I suspect -- and her makeup is a mess, but the dress itself is surprisingly elegant and delicate. I think it ALMOST works. (How can someone with such a pretty head do so many crazy things to it?)

Evangeline Lilly and Lee Pace

Actually, the longer I look at this dress, the less I like it. I'm just going to focus on the Pie Maker.

Evangeline Lilly and Richard Armitage

And here, on Richard Armitage, who looks snazzy in plaid. Do we think she just needed a red lip? Let's discuss.

Mostly Well Played, Evangeline Lilly?

I TOTALLY threw Lee Pace and Richard Armitage in here for you guys. Don't ever say I don't love you. [Photos: Getty, Splash]