Betty Gilpin
It's the sleeves for me. When they're designed to hide your hands, they just make you look like a nervous tenth-grader. The skirt is great, but I even think a plain white tee would have been... more confident?
Jake McDorman
Between the hair and the slippers, he is dressed as the guy at your high school reunion who makes his own soap and insists on reading you his poetry and making you guess which celebrity it's about.
Tom Wlaschiha
Snazzy shirt, Father! (He plays a priest.)
Chris Diamantopoulos, Becki Newton
Chris is really trying that unbuttoned shirt, isn't he? If this man tries to sell you a boat, do not trust it. (I wish they had cast Becki Newton as, like, an associate nun. I always like her, even if I am not enamored of her clothes here.)
Elizabeth Marvel
The last time I saw her in something, she was a shadowy evil overlord on Manifest's first season (I think? Maybe also second?), and someone murdered her. Apparently she has rebounded straight into some pajamas that are prompting my second Yo Gabba Gabba reference in a week, as all of those details look like things that would drift past during a musical number.
David Arquette
Congratulations to David for stumbling into just the right amount of ruffle.
Rosanna Arquette
Rosanna came out to support her brother, and in the process was incorrectly captioned as "Betty Gilpin." A good outing!
Vella Lovell
I love the color combo on this dress. The shoes fight with it a little -- I think I would have gone with navy, because it would read as neutral.
Jackie Tohn
Jackie is here for her girl from GLOW, which I love. She looks super, and now I want her and Lizzy Caplan to play sisters in something. Not the nun variety of sister, obviously. I felt I should clarify, given the subject matter.
Andy McQueen
He just played a bad guy in Outer Banks, and was actually pretty good. Not nearly as dapper and smiley as he is here.