Timothée Chalamet in custom Givenchy
I actually think this 'fit is good, but so much of this man's power is in his coif. He was the butt of a lot of -- deserved! -- cracks last night and he took it in good form and deserves props for being a good sport. (I do think he and his team need to regroup a little, PR-wise, but he'll be fine. He IS a good actor.) It's for the best that this facial hair choice is not being immortalized for him.
Gwyneth Paltrow in Armani
This is fine, but perhaps a bit boring....
Gwyneth Paltrow in Armani
...PERHAPS NOT? This sheer side inset actually reminds me of a Stella McCartney design that EVERYONE was wearing like ten years ago, to the point where I thought this might be Stella -- they ARE friends. The jewels, however, are perfect.
Emma Stone in custom Louis Vuitton
The top of this says Jane Austen, the rest of it says, "I'm not going to win, so don't worry about it."
Emma Stone in custom Louis Vuitton
The back is great, though. As ever is the case with Louis Vuitton, they know how to make a custom dress.
Elle Fanning in custom Givenchy
So, this dress is objectively gorgeous, and she looks wonderful in it. However, as I said in the chat -- and thank you to everyone who joined us! It was a blast! -- it's so much in her wheelhouse that it almost doesn't feel as special as it otherwise would. It's an expected turn for her; I almost wish she'd worn some wackier or more outre looks earlier in the season so that this (again, objectively SO pretty) dress felt fresher.
Ariana Greenblatt in archive John Galliano
Here me out: I suspect this is spectacular in person. It might be suffering from slightly matching the step-and-repeat.
Tamron Hall in Bibhu Mohapatra
I think Tamron Hall is ALSO sort of blending in; this also didn't look great on TV. It translated sort of...blobby, because of the cape detailing. A VERY rare misstep for Tamron, but she can take comfort in knowing her entire head looks terrific.
Tig Notaro
Tig looks DAPPER in this; the fit is perfect. BEYOND correct. (Would a sparkly pin have added to this, though?)
Priyanka Chopra Jonas and Nick Jonas
I am lightly underwhelmed by this but Nick looks good and also Priyanka's necklace is OUTSTANDING so maybe it all averages out to around a B-.
Mia Goth in Dior
This is beautiful and it is also fancy 1970s bedroom curtains; funny how that works.
Danielle Brooks
This dress is...a bit of a mess. Yes, you are seeing boob tape. Yes, the one side of it is strapped to her leg by her...shoulder...curtain. It sincerely just does not make sense. HOWEVER. Her head looks great and that, combined with the shiny satin shoulder pads, makes Danielle look like the newest star of a 1980s nighttime soap opera, WHICH SHE SHOULD BE. Can someone PLEASE get on this?
Molly Sims in Monique Lhuillier
This is pretty, if also definitely in the realm of the bridesmaid dress.
Felicity Jones in Prada
This was VERY unpopular with the E! panel but -- although I agree with them that a redder lip would not go amiss -- I actually quite like it.
Felicity Jones in Prada
It's great in motion. It's a fun color. The fit works. Let Felicity live!
Keltie Knight
And this was not hugely popular in the chat, but I also like THIS. Yes, she looks like a highlighter, but in a good way!