Mandy Moore in Stella McCartney

This is not rocking my world. I love the shorter hair she's got right now, but I think this needed to be styled to be more fun? I also feel like the pants look like leggings. I like pants better when they look like pants.

Melanie Liburd in SemSem and Errmano Scervino

I WANT to like this, and she is so gorgeous -- she and Susan Kelechi Watson in scenes together is a stunning experience -- but  it just looks like someone knocked off Mandy's outfit and then gave her a sash.

Susan Kelechi Watson

Speaking of this goddess... that belt is letting her down. The rest probably is, too, but the belt is the thing that's really thwapping me in the face.

Chrissy Metz

I would have gone with red shoes here, I think. And a red lip? Anyway, I mostly like this -- the top fits well, and the pattern is fun. I can't tell whether that's a waist tie bunching up under the bodice, or if the skirt is sloppy there. I THINK it's the former? But because it looks like the latter, I wonder how necessary the tie even was. It should either LOOK more clearly like what it is, or not be there. I'd vote the latter.

Ryan Michelle Bathé, Sterling K. Brown

I suspect Ryan's bodice does not fit. I also don't like the dress, but that's not helping. SKB looks okay.

Milo Ventimiglia

I really cannot with those shoes.

Justin Hartley

But WHAT is this? He looks stuffed into that blazer, and it's like he picked it all out with his eyes closed.

Aline Brosh McKenna, Rachel Bloom

I am going to miss Crazy Ex-Girlfriend. Although -- while I would never wish for fewer episodes IN GENERAL -- I do think a couple of the episodes this season have felt like filler. But it's such a creative delight, and the kind of TV that the snooty types don't take seriously, but should. These two in their matching pill bottle outfits made me smile.

Donna Lynne Champlin

Every time a character comes on-screen, I say, "I think I'll miss you most of all," but it might be the truest of Paula. She is so funny and yet so soothing and loving and great, and warm and wonderful, and like... I need Donna to call me and say, "It's okay, cookie," like once a week.

Gabrielle Ruiz

I like this on her, and also, am I the only person who is not opposed to Valencia somehow ending up with the hot priest?

Vella Lovell

This ALSO looks good on her, even if the pants aren't completely my jam. (And I might ALSO need Vella to call me on the regular to swat away the problems that I think are so important but which are pretty stupid.)

Scott Michael Foster

I am Team Nathanial, by the way.

Pete Gardner

And I want him to end up with his Josh. I know their breakup has been healthy, and that they are not real people, but... they are the best and I'm invested. Oh, God, what will I do without Darryl Whitefeather? HE might need to call me once a week to fret about things and then hug it out and conclude that simply caring as much as we do will somehow be our salvation.

Gina Rodriguez

She looks nice. If we're going to do the boring Nudist shoes, shouldn't they at least be black here?

Andrea Navedo

She looks awesome. I stopped watching Jane the Virgin, but I do love Xo and Rogelio, obviously.

Jaime Cavil

SPEAK OF THE DEVIL.

Yael Grobglas

This is 85 percent great, and 15 percent perplexing, as if she glued a big white triangle to try and close up the slit as best she could.

Brett Dier

Reviews for the final Jane season are great, but I feel like I can't consider reinvesting if Michael is really back. I quit the show when she picked him way back in whatever season that was, because I am so anti-Michael, for whatever reason.

Amy Poehler

This works, but I wish the shoes were a touch less orthopedic.

Retta

That dress says TREAT YO SELF all over it, which was Donna's anthem on Parks & Rec, so it's hard to dislike it... but, you know, from an actual design and construction standpoint, I definitely dislike it.

Aubrey Plaza

Aub, were you feeling left out of Fug Madness?

Chris Pratt

Sure.

Aziz Ansari, Adam Scott

Present and accounted for!

Nick Offerman

I hope he's growing his head-suit back into what it was on last season of Makin' It. Also, I approve of the stripes most heartily.

Jim O'Heir

I'm very invested in knowing that Jerry is okay. I kind of want Jim to tuck in his shirt, but whatever. He looks like Jerry, and he's gonna go home to Christie Brinkley and be loved.

Rashida Jones

Ann Perkins also looks fine. I feel like she REALLY wanted to wear the blazer, so she tied it in with the shoes, and it mostly works.

Rob Lowe

Oh, Rob. Two blues, green shoes, and a black jacket? You can do more.

Jay Hernandez

Magnum looks fine, but is anyone watching that show? Could he POSSIBLY really be any kind of Magnum?

Lucas Till

Ditto faux-MacGyver. I'm playing the escape game right now that uses some art from the original, and Richard Dean Anderson, THOU ART NOT.

Tristin Mays

So SHE'S the Tampa Bay Lightning fan!

Sonequa Martin-Green

This isn't worthy of her at ALL. I don't even really get the embellishments around the wrists and shoulders and neck, and the pants are... sigh.

Meaghan Rath

"So this is how it looks BEFORE I throw them in the dryer and shrink them. Commit it to memory, and then let's see if my plan works."

Anthony Rapp

I am confused by the logic of some of these layers.

Wilson Cruz

Ending on an up note!

Look, It's A Plethora of Paleyfests

Results are deeply mixed.