Blake Lively

"You look like a romantic lead in an old Hollywood musical," Blake said to herself, cocking her chin confidently. "No one else will have the guts to try this."

Anne Hathaway

"You look like a romantic lead in an old Hollywood musical," Anne said to herself, cocking her chin confidently. "No one else will have the guts to try this."

Elizabeth Berkley

"You look like Blake Lively's understudy as the romantic lead in an old Hollywood musical," Elizabeth said to herself. "No one else will have the guts to try this."

Rosie Huntington-Whiteley

"I'm just hoping people will think I AM Blake Lively."

Katherine Langford

Aw, man. I was JUST saying that her fashion had gotten a little lighter and brighter, and less like she's the youngest widow in her neighborhood, and then she goes and trots out this.

Maria Sharapova

That looks like a textile she bought for her throw pillows.

Martha Stewart

That is the biggest clutch I've ever seen. It's more of a... gilded manila envelope.

Yihan Chen

That dress is GORGEOUS and I'm so bummed we're seeing it at this party instead of on the Emmy red carpet. Maybe we still can.

Ansel Elgort

I can't with this one.

Tracee Ellis Ross

I can't really tell what this outfit is, entirely, but I get the gist and I think she accessorized it superbly.

Tom Hiddleston

He's really leaning into a more Outlander vibe with his head.

Camilla Belle

Stunning. It's so simple but it's divine.

Lily Aldridge

That's good, too. I feel like Lily, right here, is what Emily Ratajkowski should want to be.

Allison Williams

That's fine, but... functionally bland.

Rose Byrne

I'd like this better without the sleeves, I think. I also do like the red shoes, but they only really tie in if she's holding the clutch, which presumably she wasn't the WHOLE night. Although I guess at those times she would've been sitting and having dinner, so no one could see her feet.

Jessica Chastain

That's quite good, and she picked the perfect lipstick to make sure the yellow didn't wash her out.

Poppy Delevingne

This looks a bit musty.

Priyanka Chopra

Well. I love houndstooth, and if I'm not mistaken, isn't that GLITTERING houndstooth?

with Nick Jonas

I still can't take these two totally seriously; bless them both, if they are really in love, but this looks less cuddly and more like she's about to give him the Vulcan neck pinch.

Sheryl Crow

I have it on good authority that all she wants to do is have some fun, and this is a good start.

Kanye West

I reject his feet entirely.

Iman

Saving the best for last. I don't even know if I like this, but I also LOVE IT. Such is the magic of Iman.

No One Threw Any Shoes at Ralph Lauren's 50th Anniversary Party

But Kanye did kick a reporter off the red carpet, and three women wore the same-ish suit.