Blake Lively in Sergio Hudson
She looks great. This is a full runway look, which we know is how she likes to roll, and it works on her. But it's JUST enough of a nighttime outfit that her makeup might read too day? That's a small thing, though. She's giving it a chill, casual vibe even though that plunge is neither chill nor casual, and it works.
Ryan Reynolds
This, though... This needed a white shirt, yes? That shirt itself is not super, color-wise, but it's also a little janky and may not fit. And the shoes are a little jarring. An attempt was made!
Anne Hathaway
Everyone went nuts when Anne brought back the Devil Wears Prada bangs, but my hot take is that they don't suit her. YES, I SAID IT. Her outfit is fine -- I assume it's a top and pants, and not a jumpsuit with a purely decorative belt -- but it sits low enough that a necklace might have been useful. BUT, at least she and Blake went with stuff that'll be comfortable for sitting in a theater chair all night, unlike...
Deborra-Lee Furness
... Deborra-Lee, Hugh's wife, who I think seems like an absolute hoot and who is wearing something sincerely perplexing to me, like, on a descriptive level. She looks like she's wearing The Flying Nun as a shawl.
Seth Meyers
Seth and his wife Alexi look great. I will be very sad if it's ever revealed that he sucks. The story about his wife giving birth in their building lobby is quite something.
Peter Hermann and Mariska Hargitay
These are also sensible theater-going duds. This photo makes me laugh. It looks like he's noticed something in her hair and can't decide what to do about it, or what it even is.
Haley Swindal
Haley was in Anastasia, and I question the wisdom of a skirt that's one giant ode to graduation tassels.
Brian Stokes Mitchell, Allyson Tucker
I have no idea what is going on with her outfit, but the skirt is cool? His paisley is the star.
Cynthia Nixon
And just like that, Cynthia had another project to talk about instead (she's in The Gilded Age), and she glowed with relief.