Fug or Fab: Rachel McAdams

I started out planning to give this a Well Played:

It fits, she looks shapely, the shoes are sassy, her hair is nice and not pink... but then I noticed that I think the shoes are actually translucent (are those toes I see before me?) and something about her makeup isn't sitting quite right with me -- she doesn't look dewy so much as perhaps like she doesn't feel great and was rallying through a head cold -- and then of course I can NEVER decide if the crinkled style is flattering in this instance or an ill-advised ode to the accordion. And that leaves me with cold feet.